The pen hovers over a blank line. Successor trustee. You have two children. You love them both, and the last thing you want is for either one to feel passed over. So why not write both names?
That instinct comes from love. I see it in my office all the time. Choosing a trustee, the person who will manage your trust when you can’t, should never feel like ranking your children.
But here is what I tell every parent who asks: co-trustees often means no trustee. Two people who both have to be reachable, both have to agree, and both have to sign can bring the administration of your trust to a standstill at the exact moment your family needs it to work.
The good news is that you don’t have to choose between fairness and a plan that works. Your children can receive equal inheritances without holding identical jobs. When choosing a trustee, the question isn’t whether two names look fair on paper. It’s whether the person you name can carry out your wishes when real decisions need to be made.
Estate Planning Awareness Week is a good moment to look past whether you have a trust and ask whether the people you named are still the right fit.
Choosing a Trustee Is About the Job, Not Birth Order
This article is about choosing a successor trustee: the person who steps in when you can no longer manage your trust, or after you die. That person has to understand your trust’s instructions, find the assets it holds, keep records, and keep your beneficiaries informed. Depending on your plan, they may also maintain or sell real estate, oversee investments, and work with a CPA on tax filings.
A trustee is also a fiduciary. That means they are legally required to manage trust property for the people the trust serves, not for their own convenience. Your trust and California law define the duties. This is real work. It is not an honorary title.
So your oldest child isn’t automatically the right choice. Neither is the one who earns the most or lives the closest. Those details may matter, but they don’t tell you whether someone follows through, stays calm in a disagreement, or knows when to call a professional.
Before choosing a trustee, ask yourself:
- Does this person have the time to respond, follow up, and keep good records?
- Can they explain a decision without getting defensive?
- Will they follow your instructions, even when a sibling pushes back?
- Will they work with your attorney, CPA, and financial advisor?
- Can they reach the property and records if they need to?
Then ask them. Someone who loves you can still say no to this job, and it’s far better to hear that now. A willing backup serves your family better than a first choice who said yes out of obligation.
The bottom line: Choose a trustee for the work involved, not as a reward for being your child.
Should Your Children Be Co-Trustees? Two Names Don’t Mean Twice the Help
Many parents picture it this way: one child handles the numbers, the other handles the house. It sounds efficient. In practice, an informal plan to split the work doesn’t split the legal responsibility. Each co-trustee is responsible for everything.
It helps to know the difference between two common setups:
- Co-trustees serve at the same time, side by side.
- A successor trustee with a backup means one person serves, and the next person steps in only if the first can’t or stops serving.
Naming your daughter as trustee and your son as her backup is a very different plan than naming them both to act at once.
Here’s why that matters. In California, unless your trust says otherwise, co-trustees must act unanimously (California Probate Code section 15620). Not by majority. Not whoever gets there first. Together. That means your co-trustees have to:
- Be reachable. If one lives in locally and the other lives out of state or travels for work, every decision waits on the slower inbox.
- Sign together. Banks, title companies, and brokerages often want both trustees on the paperwork.
- Agree. Every time.
Some families assume their children “can just vote.” With two people, there is no majority. A one-to-one split is a deadlock. And when co-trustees can’t break a deadlock, the next stop is often the court. Keeping your family out of court is exactly what your trust was supposed to do.
Picture a $12,000 repair the trust-owned house needs before it can sell. One child wants to approve it today. The other wants another estimate. Neither is being unreasonable. But while they go back and forth, the property taxes, insurance, and utilities keep coming due, and a routine repair turns into a personal argument.
The bottom line: Two trustees means two schedules, two signatures, and two opinions on every decision. For most families, one trustee with a clear backup works far better.
Equal Love Doesn’t Require Identical Roles
Imagine your children sitting across the table from each other after you’re gone. One is following the trust’s instructions. The other is asking when the money will be available. Their relationship now carries a financial weight it never had before.
That doesn’t mean a child should never serve as trustee. Children serve as trustee, and as beneficiary at the same time, all the time. It means choosing a trustee requires you to think about the pressure the arrangement creates. Your family’s history doesn’t disappear because everyone signs a form.
I would much rather talk about that pressure with you now than leave your children to work it out while they’re grieving. If one child already carries most of the family responsibilities and the other resents feeling supervised, joint authority can deepen the very pattern you hoped to avoid.
Here are the arrangements I usually discuss with families:
- One child serves, with the other named as backup. This is where I start for most families.
- A second backup is named, in case neither child can serve.
- A corporate trustee or professional fiduciary serves, when no child is a good fit or family tension is already high.
- A family member serves with professional support, with the trust directing them to work with your attorney, CPA, and financial advisor.
None of these is automatically right. Corporate trustees and professional fiduciaries charge fees and have their own requirements for accepting a trust. A family member brings personal knowledge but may need outside help. Ask professionals what they charge, what assets they accept, and how they communicate. Ask family members what support they would need.
Are you worried that it’s unfair for one child to do all the work? In California, a trustee is generally entitled to reasonable compensation unless the trust says otherwise. And the trustee must keep the other beneficiaries informed and account for the trust, so your other child is protected. When choosing a trustee, you are building a working arrangement, not filling in a blank.
The bottom line: Giving your children different roles can be an act of care. It is not a statement that you love one of them more.
Prepare Your Successor Trustee Before They’re Needed
Suppose you choose the right person but never tell them. They find out after you land in the hospital, staring at accounts they can’t identify and instructions they’ve never read. You made a good choice. You just never set them up to carry it out.
Being named isn’t the same as being in charge. Your trust spells out when your successor steps in. I make sure you understand those conditions, so your family doesn’t confuse being named with being authorized to act.
Your trustee also doesn’t automatically control everything you own. Their authority covers what is held in your trust. Other assets may be handled by your agent under a power of attorney, your executor, or the beneficiaries you named on an account. That’s why all of the roles in your plan need to work together.
Give your trustee a secure starting point: where your current trust is kept, a summary of your assets, and contact information for your attorney, CPA, and financial advisor. You don’t need to hand anyone the keys to every account today. You do need the right people to know who to call and where to find what they’re authorized to see.
The bottom line: Your choice works best when your trustee understands the role, knows when their authority begins, and knows where to find help.
Review Your Trustee Choice as Life Changes
Your child can be an excellent choice today and need to step aside later. A move, an illness, a demanding job, or a shift in family relationships can change what someone can take on. Choosing a trustee is not a one-time decision, so review your backups as carefully as your first choice.
This is one reason I work with families as a Personal Family Lawyer® firm. We revisit your plan as your life changes. And when your family needs guidance, they call someone who already knows your plan and the reasons behind it.
The bottom line: Keeping your decision-makers prepared is part of caring for your family. It isn’t finished the day you sign your trust.
As a Personal Family Lawyer® firm, I help you create a Life & Legacy Plan that reflects your family, your assets, and the relationships you want to protect. I don’t do one-size-fits-all planning. Together, we decide who should serve, who backs them up, what support they’ll need, and how it all fits the rest of your plan. And the relationship doesn’t end when the documents are signed. When something happens, your family knows to call me.
If you’re choosing a trustee and still feel torn between your children, let’s talk it through before anyone feels overlooked. Schedule a discovery call with our office. We’ll learn about your family, answer your first questions, and help you decide whether a Life & Legacy Planning® Session is the right next step.
This article is a service of Debbie Babb Law, a Personal Family Lawyer® Firm. We do not just draft documents. We help you make informed and empowered decisions about life and death, for yourself and the people you love. That is why we offer a Life & Legacy Planning® Session, during which you can become more financially organized and make thoughtful decisions for the people who matter most.
The content is sourced from Personal Family Lawyer for use by Personal Family Lawyer firms, a source believed to be providing accurate information. This material was created for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as ERISA, tax, legal, or investment advice. If you are seeking legal advice specific to your needs, such advice services must be obtained on your own, separate from this educational material.
© 2026 Debbie Babb Law
